Todays session will focus on utilitarianism and the next on tuesday, 4th october will look at deontology. Law in 2000, spell out the case against the fact value dichotomy as. Moore 39 i propose, then, to begin by an examination of mills utilitarianism. Corporate social responsibility, utilitarianism, and the. Apr 12, 2017 julian jacobs 19 is a senior staff writer and interviews associate at bpr concentrating in philosophy, politics, and economics ppe. It holds that the greatest good is happiness and freedom from pain and suffering.
Posner, utilitarianism, economics, and legal theory, 8 j. Brandt and lyons have tried to show that these two forms of utilitarianism are actually equivalent. Utilitarianism john stuart mill mcmaster faculty of social. It was conceived as a way to think about the legal system, and to improve it, on the basis of a single coherent rational. It assumes that individual subjective utilities and costs can be added, subtracted, and. The justice of economics duke law scholarship repository. It also suggests that the failure of the two groups to develop an alliance is tied to weaknesses of the critical legal studies cls movement.
Given some idealizing assumptions about interpersonal and intrapersonal comparisons, they presuppose that any individual goodness measure can be transformed into any. The dominant form of consequentialism is utilitarianism. Environmental studies and utilitarian ethics brian g. Hart was suggesting that utilitarianism preceded economics. Rawlsa s theory of justice from a utilitarian perspective. A philosophy that bases the moral worth of an action upon the number of people it gives happiness or pleasure to.
It is a form of consequentialism, meaning that the moral worth of an action is determined by its outcome. Jeremy benthams 17481832 principle of utility is open to the objection that it may well sacrifice the rights of the minority for the sake of the happiness of the majority. Posner, utilitarianism, economics, and legal theory, 8 journal of legal studies 103 1979. Utilitarianism is a family of moral and political philosophies according to which general utility or social welfare is ultimately the sole ethical value or good to be maximized. Utilitarianism and wealth transfer taxation university of arkansas. That is a book which contains an admirably clear and fair discussion of many ethical principles and methods. Legal positivism and the natural law theory of positive law are rival views about what is law and what is its relation to justicemorality. Utilitarianism an ethical theory according to which the rightness and wrongness of acts depends entirely on facts about the maximization of overall wellbeing. Whether there are any agent neutral theories that are not consequentialist is not so clear, because some recent work in moral philosophy suggests that any plausible moral theory can be recast as a consequentialist theory. It is true that similar confusion and uncertainty, and in some cases similar discordance, exist respecting the first principles of all the sciences, not excepting that which is deemed the most certain of them. Drawing on the social contract theories of locke, rousseau, and kant, rawls argues that the best society would be. Utilitarianism john stuart mill mcmaster faculty of. The term utilitarianism is, at the present day, in common use, and is supposed to designate a doctrine or method with which we are all familiar.
Proponents of law and economics believe that all law should be based on a costbenefit analysis in which judges and lawmakers seek to maximize societal wealth in the most efficient fashion. A utilitarian philosophy, when directed to making social, economic, or political decisions, aims for the betterment of society. I consider it an attractive objective to guide social choice generally, but do not pursue the argument for that position in this article. So utilitarianism principle is the central theme of any of the economic systems. Django rogers john rawlss influential work, a theory of justice, represents and attempt to give a moral justification for the workings of egalitarian democracy. Utilitarianism holds that the most ethical choice is the one that will produce the greatest good for the greatest number. Pdf this paper argues that people from all walks of life are required to make ethical decisions. Posner, the ethical and political basis of the efficiency norm in common law. The purpose of satisfying the greatest good for greatest number seems logical, practical and realistic. Reductivism is underpinned by the theory of moral reasoning known as utilitarianism,which maintains that an act. In the sociological jurisprudence, benthams works on theory.
Utilitarianism is an ethical theory that determines right from wrong by focusing on outcomes. Mill exposes not a few simple mistakes which are very likely to be made by those who. It seems tome that thecritique of utilitarianism offered by environmentalists and others is very often on target. It is the only moral framework that can be used to justify military force or. Pdf this paper argues that people from all walks of life are. Business implications utilitarian principles in business utilitarianism may be employed in any business decisionmaking process that seeks to maximize positive. In describing economic analysis of law as inspired by utilitarianism, h. I we can give an easy model of the value of an action. It is important to understand utilitarianism as it forms the basic tenants of legal theory and function of laws. Kronman, wealth maximization as a normative principle, 9 j.
Posner, utilitarianism, economics, and legal theory, 8, j. The meaning of utilitarianism henry sidgwick defining utilitarianism 1. Third, john stuart mill offered his own account of the theory in his 1861 essay. Animal law more of an increase in the happiness of all affected by it than any altemative action, and wrong if it does not. The economic concept of utility borrows a great deal from jeremy benthams notions of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism has been adopted and transformed in contemporary political theory into welfare economics. But both hold equally that morality must be deduced from prin ciples.
Utilitarianism and prioritarianism make a strong assumption about measures of how good lotteries over histories are for individuals, or for short, individual goodness measures. Utilitarianism is a comprehensive doctrine claiming that the greatest amount of happiness is an end that should exclusively guide all actions of both government and individuals. A utilitarian critique 493 one can effect a compromise between these welfarist theories, mixing the benefitmaximizing principle of utilitarianism with the equalizing principle of welfare egalitarianism. Utilitarianism law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Utilitarianism is a moral theory that advocates actions that promote overall happiness or pleasure and rejects actions that cause unhappiness or harm. Utilitarianism is founded on the an underlying hedonistic philosophy. He combined austrian economics with a fervent commitment to individual liberty. The following passages from that essay among others. Criticisms of utilitarianism intuitively speaking, utilitarianism appears to be an extremely attractive philosophy. It stresses the influence of utilitarianism in economics in general and in. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks. In all of these fields, utilitarianism has its proponents and utilitarian.
Benthams radical critique of common law theory and. James and mary lassiter associate professor of law, university of kentucky. Bentham believed that we should only factor the quantity of pleasure, or to what extent it provides pleasure in the greatest amount to the greatest number of people. The fact that people value the happiness of those close to them more than that of strangers makes utilitarianism personally unacceptable to many, but it may still be a proper principle for. According to the textbook definition, of course, utilitarianism just is the combination of a certain sort of theory of the.
This philosophy identifies pleasure as beneficial and pain as detrimental to a persons wellbeing. Utilitarianism i the most common form of consequentialism is utilitarianism i utilitarianism combines consequentialism with the claim that the only valuable consequence is pleasure, and the only disvaluable consequence is pain. Pdf the utilitarian theory of lawan analysis researchgate. First, the term ethics has been defined, and the relationship between the utilitarianism theory, morality and the nature of morality explored. Utilitarianism is a family of consequentialist ethical theories that promotes actions that maximize happiness and wellbeing for the affected individuals. This is the correct sequence if the topic is legal theory as harts was, but not if one is speaking of economics more broadly. Utilitarianism is the social philosophy, legal theory and ethical system, primarily associated with jeremy bentham and his followers in 19th century britain. Chapter 11 utilitarianism and the theory of justice. Jeremy bentham was a philosopher, economist, jurist, and legal reformer and the founder of modern utilitarianism, an ethical theory holding that actions are morally right if they tend to promote happiness or pleasure and morally wrong if they tend to promote unhappiness or pain among all those affected by them. While utilitarianism assumes that morality, the good, is purely subjective to each individual, it assumes on the other hand that these subjective desires can be added, subtracted, and weighed across the various individuals in society. Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory in that it is concerned with the consequences of the moral judgment, the outcome of the costbenefit analysis. Utilitarianism, economics, and legal theory the journal.
Businessmen and women like benthams version of utilitarianism because it provides an easy to use costbenefit way of working out what is right and what is wrong. Teleology, utilitarianism, and christian ethics 603 states of affairs in which they result. In this chapter, we survey a set of results in socialchoice theory that provides an axiomatic basis for generalized utilitarianism and, in some cases, utilitarianism itself. Part i of the article traces the emergence of the theory from earlier scientific studies of tort law and discusses recurrent criticisms of it. To test brandts and lyonss equivalence thesis, a decisiontheoretical model for utilitarian theory is proposed. On the one hand the standard of right and wrong, on the other the chain of causes and effects, are. Not only that as it is an ethical concept, economics will become normative science. Rawlss theory of justice from a utilitarian perspective t. Utilitarianism 7 as well as truth and falsehood, are questions of observation and experi ence.
Utilitarianism tells us that it is the happiness or well being of sentient beings that is the valuable thing. He is a former opinions columnist for the brown daily herald and the founding editorinchief of the brown university journal of philosophy, politics, and economics jppe. This article is designed as an introduction to the positive economic theory. Maximization the view that the value of a state of affairs should be made as great as possible. We recall that a simplified description of benthams utilitarianism said that the greatest good could be achieved by bringing the most happiness to the largest number. I some utilitarians even allow for there to be quanti able units of pain and pleasure. It is a philosophical theory of morality or how one should act which has historical roots within the liberal tradition.
The collapse of the factvalue dichotomy and other essays. Utilitarianism but which states of affairs are valuable and which states of affairs are not. Utilitarianism, the view that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness, is no longer taken seriously either as a moral principle or as a theory of tort law. But on closer examination, it appears to be applied to several distinct theories, having no necessary connexion with one. Although the law of diminishing marginal utility on income provides a justification for redistribution in a limited capacity, utilitarians tend to recognize that economic liberties and competition are essential to increasing state wealth.
John stuart mill 18061873, himself a utilitarian, sought to rescue utilitarianism from this. My intention in this paper is not to defend utilitarianism or costbenefit analysis. But is it fair to say that economics is competing with another system, or is the issue incorrectly framed. Law and economics is a school of modern utilitarianism that has achieved prominence in legal circles. A passing remark is all that needs be given to the ignorant blunder of supposing that those who stand up for utility as the test of right and wrong, use the term in that restricted and merely colloquial sense in which utility is opposed to pleasure. Utilitarianism and wealth transfer taxation school of law. It offers a simplicity that many other philosophical approaches lack and in particular cuts through the mish mash of moral rules favoured by deontological thinkers. Consequentialist decision theory and utilitarian ethics. There is an interesting overlap between philosophy and economics. Utilitarianism, economics, and legal theory by richard a. Today legal theorists who discuss utilitarianism tend to reject it as a basis of normative legal theory. But the modern tendency is to make economics a positive science. While utilitarianism assumes that morality, the good, is purely subjective to each individual, it assumes on the other hand. An introduction to mills utilitarian ethics explicitly considered themselves utilitarians.
A utilitarian philosophy is used when making social, economic or. Although different varieties of utilitarianism admit different characterizations, the basic idea behind all of them is to in some sense maximize utility, which is often defined in terms of wellbeing or related concepts. Utilitarianism was radical in the sense that it is a theory that is aimed at defining one simple basis that can be applied when making any ethical decision. Dec 11, 2016 utilitarianism is a family of moral and political philosophies according to which general utility or social welfare is ultimately the sole ethical value or good to be maximized. After describing the difficulties of act utilitarianism, rule utilitarianism is discussed as a possibly superior alternative. Rule utilitarianism and decision theory springerlink. Pdf available in ssrn electronic journal june 2009 with 4,206 reads. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months. Author links open overlay panel charles blackorby 1 walter bossert 2 david donaldson 3. This essay entails a detailed analysis of the ethical as well as the legal issues of the case study that has been provided, within the framework of the ethical theory of utilitarianism. The changing status of utilitarianism in environmental ethics utilitarianism, in its most traditional form, is both a theory of the good and a theory of the right. As is pointed out in section 10, however, the individual welfare functions which ought to be added have a very di. It tells each of us to promote the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
Utilitarianism as an independent ethical position only arose in the eighteenth century however fundamental utilitarian ideas can be found in the thoughts of philosophers such as aristotle. The economist argues that economics describes the true underlying rationality of torts law. It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do, as well as to determine what we shall do. The collapse of the fact value dichotomy and other essays hilary putnam. Mill, utilitarianism 1863 a brief overview of the reading. In torts, deontological theories argue against the economic analysis of tort law and for the idea that tort law is best explained by a theory of corrective justice. Utilitarianism, in normative ethics, a tradition stemming from the late 18th and 19thcentury english philosophers and economists jeremy bentham and john stuart mill according to which an action is right if it tends to promote happiness and wrong if it tends to produce the reverse of happiness. Your use of this heinonline pdf indicates your acceptance. This article explores the possible convergence between the capabilities approach and utilitarianism to specify csr. Structures of normative theories the monist 76 1993 2240.
First, it reappraises the major transformations which the utilitarian approach to human behavior has undergone in economics in search for a. It is an egalitarian theory no one person is worth more. Utilitarianism an ethical theory according to which the. Normative economics endorsed a hedonistic version of utilitarianism from the latter part of the 18th century well into the 20th century. Proponents of law and economics believe that all law should be based on a costbenefit analysis in which judges and lawmakers seek to maximize. The project gutenberg ebook of utilitarianism, by john stuart. For a recent statement of the efficiency theory of the common law, see posner, some uses and abuses of economics in law, 46 u. Explanation incapacitation is a reductivist or forward looking justification for punishment. In spite of all the criticisms, the formula of the greatest happiness of the greatest number still remains valuable in economics and politics.
Corporate social responsibility, utilitarianism, and the capabilities approach cecile renouard abstract. It defends the idea that this key issue is related to the anthropological perspective that underpins. Natural law theory of morality i even things which are not manmade e. Pdf study on the rationality of utilitarian philosophy of lawan. It is a form of consequentialism, meaning that the moral worth of. Utilitarianism law and legal definition utilitarianism is a philosophical and economic doctrine that the best social policy is that which does the most good for the greatest number of people. The case of john stuart mill daniel jacobson bowling green state university in this essay i will argue, flouting paradox, that mill was a utilitarian but not a consequentialist. Jeremy bentham, the founder of the utilitarian movement in nineteenth century england, accepted the incompatibility of utilitarianism and the rights of man, and rejected talk of the latter as anarchical fallacies. A lockean theory of intellectual property 1997 21 hamline l rev 65. Murray rothbard offers a wideranging critique of utilitarian economics.
1121 265 1116 714 1310 332 1164 1241 539 821 523 767 296 1000 242 926 248 615 926 281 1168 1274 994 225 514 394 520 209 1074